FirstChoiceCandy All Flavor Saltwater Taffy (Assorted, 5 Pound (Pack of 1))

I got this for my mom and her bf in the nursing home. They ate the whole first bag so fast I had to order more and they ration it now. It's proper taffy with many flavors and colors. My people have no teeth and that works because there's nothing to get stuck on. They just suck on the taffy and enjoy. I highly recommend, and a good price too! I didn't keep it for myself because it threatened to pull a filling out, the way I was chewing them. But Ellie and Jimmy love it because it's just like at the shore.

I had ordered from this same link back in 2021 and the taffy was Taffy Town brand. It was excellent, soft, flavorful, and loved by all in our home. Fast forward to 2022 - I looked up the item in my previously ordered list on Amazon and followed the link to buy it again thinking I was getting the same taffy. It showed up and some were melted, but only certain colors (pink and blue), and was all over the bag and all the taffy - so we had to try and wipe all the sticky off of the taffy before placing it out to eat. Most of the flavors taste the same, only a couple have a distinct taste, and it was all hard within a few weeks. The brand is no longer Taffy Town, it is First Choice Candy and ended up being thrown away because it is awful. I will never order this again. If you are looking for Taffy Town Taffy this is not it.

So delicious and flavorful

I've bought this taffy and a few other brands several times so far off amazon:- It's by far the cheapest- The softest saltwater taffy I've tried- Flavors are a bit muted, and just only alright.- Sometimes you get a bag that slightly melted and most pieces become a pain to remove from the wrapper. Other brands never had this issue.- The pieces of taffy tend to be a bit small, and inconsistent in shape.- There's not really any "controversial" flavors, like cinnamon included.Overall, it's good enough if you want something cheap. However, if you get a bag that melted slightly, it'll be a frustrating experience. People who know what good taffy tastes like may be disappointed.

There is a nice variety of flavors included. The taffy is soft and fresh. However, I took one star off because there were three flavors that I believe didn’t get any sugar in the mix. They were extremely sour and inedible. These flavors also tended to stick extremely to the wax paper also. I had to throw out quite a bit of the bag because of this. But I loved the other flavors! Even the licorice flavor wasn’t horrendous. I don’t usually eat the black licorice flavors

My private stash of delight

Now granted I was really excited about receiving this package. To my surprise it arrived with no issues. When i decided to open this package . I was so disappointed. There's no cinnamon in this candy. It's to soft, but chewy and has a hint of cinnamon but not quite the flavor I was expecting. I will eat this because I spent my money on this. If you are looking the cinnamon flavor salt water taffy. This not it!! It's not a bad taste, but not cinnamon with that kick. You actually can look at the candy and tell it's different. With the real cinnamon candy 🍬 it has a dark red area and light pink outside coloring. These have a slight darker pink area (barely can see it) that blends in with the light pink outside area. I gave 2 stars because people pay their money and expect to get exactly what the product says it is. I'm very disappointed.

As you can see almost gone that should tell you everything you need to know.