Peanut Butter & Co. Smooth Operator Peanut Butter, Non-GMO Project Verified, Gluten Free, Vegan, 16 Ounce (Pack of 2)

Peanut butter as it was meant to taste. Not quite as “bare bones” as brands like Deaf Smith, and it does contain cane sugar and palm oil so it hasn’t separated, but it still tastes more of salted roasted peanuts than any of those big name brands that are filled with sweeteners and hydrogenated fats. Definitely worth buying if you want a more natural tasting peanut butter.

Best peanut butter ever

I only have this to say. This, is the best peanut butter I've ever had in my life. I can't stop eating it. Perfect taste, consistency and something unique about it I can't put my finger on. Maybe because it's organic and non GMO, AND Project Verified so I get to have REAL, actual peanut butter and not the fake, filler after taste I've come to despise in our food. I can not think how they can possibly top this rendition(Smooth Operator), but I'll be buying every single kind just out of curiosity. I don't know who could rate it less than 5 stars. They must not be true peanut butter lovers and should go back to Jif, which leaves more for me, so that works just fine.

I've been getting this peanut butter for a bit over year now from Amazon's Subscribe and Save service. I've never been disappointed with it, and the price is far superior this way than buying it in my local market. Smooth Operator is very creamy, and indeed smooth. It has a nice roasted peanut taste, with just a touch of sweetness. It also smells marvelous. I use it in sandwiches, recipes, for veggies, and just eating it on its own. It works well for all uses. While the ingredients are pretty straightforward and all natural, it's still not as natural as some peanut butters that are just peanuts and salt. Still, Smooth Operator's great taste and limited amount of separating make it well worth the extra ingredients. The packages always arrive in excellent condition and the expiration dates are far enough out that I have no problem eating them before they go bad.

This is night and day difference in quality vs Jif and Skippy nastiness. It actually tastes like it came from peanuts and is not smothered in sugar. Simple and yet delicious.

Tasty, quality ingredients. Although I could have done without the white chocolate.

First of all. I ordered "smooth operator". This is "mighty maple". Am I returning this? No. Why? This is a GREAT company. I refuse to say otherwise. I will say this though. *ahem* This peanut butter has sugar crystals (crunch). It means it got cold. VERY cold. Storage issue. The consistency is some where between "smooth" and "crunchy". That's a production issue. The important thing is, it tastes good. Not as good as smooth operator (personal preference), but good. You can trust this company to be that. Good. To the sweet summer child in Q&A. Glitches happen. Just look out for them. Okay?

This is wonderful flavored peanut butter!! A great starter variety. White chocolate wonderful...this is a good, sweet peanut butter. I do not care for white chocolate, but like this pb. My 14yr old states that it tastes much like peanut butter butter cream frosting before thinning(pb, butter, pwd sugar...thinned with milk or heavy cream)...yeah, kinda, maybe a bit less sweet. Dark choc dream...this pb has a taste similar to nutella, a tad more "bitter choc" taste(in a good way-if you are a dark choc fan, you know what I mean) and obviously its a different nut, but same general flavor and mouth feel. Smooth operator...this is super flavorful, great pb! It is like homemade peanut butter that I used to make before I had 3young children(3, 2, 1...its a wonder I have time to write this review ;-)) If you have never had homemade pb and are used to store bought, the difference is amazing!!! Crunch time...this is like homemade pb I used to make with nut pieces thrown in. I cant wait to make cookies with this pb!!! If you have only had mainstream grocery store brands, you are in for a real treat!! If you have had homemade pb, you know what im talking about. I am so happy that I can have homemade peanut butter taste without all the work(pb is easy, the cleanup & storage isnt always...especially with little ones running through the house).