stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner, Stay All Day Makeup with Fine Brush Tip Lasting Satin Finish, Smudge-Proof & Transfer-Resistant

This is seriously the best liquid liner on the market. It lasts long and doesn’t budge throughout the day. It glides on easily, and is very bold looking. Easy to remove with makeup remover, but will stay put all day.

They used to sell this inside of Sephora, which is where I first experienced using this product. Hands down THE best eyeliner that I've ever used - and I use it daily. Goes on smooth and consistent, is the right shade for me personally. I mean, if you have dark brown hair and eyelashes, this looks far more natural than say... black, unless you are going for that contrast. I prefer a more subtle look ala Korean beauty standard so this one is a must for me. Stays on even after working all day, crying (yup, tested that before, too, lol), sweating, etc. Love this - I think I've ordered it at least 15 times. I like to have one on standby always, so I don't run out.

Great eyeliner - my favorite brand and type. Goes on so well and stays on.

I was looking for a good eyeliner to replace the Tarte maneater liquid liner that has been discontinued. This one almost fit the bill. I really like it, but not quite perfect for me. It somehow seems dryer even though it goes on wet. I have to shake the pen slightly before doing my 2nd eye. It stays all day, but does become slightly flaky by night. Not that I recommend sleeping in makeup, but if you do, it will be at least half flake off by morning. My maneater liner could stay put for days. This has traditional applicator vs the brush which I suspect is what makes it less wet on application. Pros: goes on easy, stays all day. Dries quickly after application, great black matte fine line color. Fantastic for fine line strokes Cons: formula or applicator a little dry, slightly flakes by evening. When applying need to gently shake to get applicator wet enough for broader strokes on one pass, or go over line a couple times.

I really like this brand for draw on eyeliner. I got the dark gray shade and like it better for work than the usual black I buy. Tube lasts a long time but do be sure to recap it. If it dries out, it's done.

The best eyeliner I've ever used and super long lasting!

Updated Review: So I originally left a 5 star review and was super thrilled with this product! It was the first I'd found that wouldn't smudge with my oily skin. I honestly don't know if something changed when I bought my second tube of eyeliner (the first one lasted me over a year - I will give it credit for that!) or if I just hadn't noticed that it wasn't waterproof the first time. After I got the new one, I decided to start using it on the bottom of my eyes as well, and that's when I started noticing it was smudging more easily and would smear if I had been crying. This is not waterproof. (At least my second tube isn't.) Also, if I rub my eyes (Which you're not supposed to do and is my fault anyway) it smears black everywhere and I have checked to make sure it's the eyeliner and not my mascara that is smearing everywhere. I will say that I still enjoy using it. It does create a beautiful, black line, as thick or as thin as you'd like it. But I have changed my review from 5 stars to 3 stars simply because I have found it's not waterproof. My previous, 5 star review: This is the best eyeliner I've ever found for not smudging. My eyelids tend to get oily throughout the day, leaving even waterproof eyeliner lines above my eyelids from looking up! I was getting so sick of it and but couldn't steadily use eyeliners with the little fine brush. This is literally a marker and you can do thin or thick lines. The ONLY downside is that it dries so fast, it's hard to wipe off if you mess up. You have to use eye makeup remover. Love this!!! Update: I had this eyeliner for more than a year and used it every day. 16 months later, it finally ran out and I love it as much as the day I bought it. You definitely get your money's worth. (I wrote this update before I realized that the second tube wasn't waterproof.)

The Stila Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is decent, but it didn’t fully meet my expectations. The fine brush tip is easy to use and the color goes on smoothly, but the formula isn’t as long-lasting on me as I hoped.It does stay put a few hours, but I noticed some fading and slight smudging by the end of the day. It also tends to dry out a bit quickly, which makes the application less consistent. Overall,it’s an okay eyeliner-not bad, but not impressive enough for the price.