Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara - with Vitamin E & Olive Oil, Lengthening Formula Extends the Look of Your Lashes up to 100% without Clumping, Flaking or Smudging, Carbon Black 0.21 oz

I have used so many mascaras in my life. More than you can count on all of your digits.That being said.. none of them were really all that great. I've used all the major brands, all the little niche brands, all the organic brands, all the drugstore ones. I think Neutrogena nailed it with this.I had never experimented with getting a different color from black but I’m not sure if that really affects much in my review.. can’t really tell the difference.Pros:Looks NATURAL.Length is phenomenal.Seperation is however much or little you want it to be.Application is easy.NO RACCOON EYES. <--- this is why I bought this and it did not let me downand its good for your lashes?? that was the ultimate selling point for me.I feel happy and comfortable wearing it everyday knowing I’m not just going to make my eyelashes fall out with this.Cons:My only complaint is as I have continued to use it, the wand seems to be getting a bit clumpy but that can be fixed with a wipe.sorry for the bad photos ;p

Nice mascara. Isn’t clumpy, flaky or smudgy. Separates my lashes really well. Good price. I will purchase this again.

This is a good mascara for a natural, no makeup makeup look. It doesn't flake badly actually. It adds more volume than lenghth.It was a little dry and chunky when I got it, but adding some rosemary oil helped.And the price is great too!

Works for my super duper sensitive eyes 👀.I have been looking for a mascara that would not irritate my eye lids. After trying many different products I finally found something that works!It doesn’t bleed or leave flaking, it’s black, doesn’t itch. Washes out really quick with water. So far so good! Will update in a few weeks. Very good price for the product.

This really did very little to make my lashes look longer. It did look very natural, no clumping or flaking, washed off with just regular face washing.

this is fantastic...base of Vit E and Olive oil, so application is smoother. It looks great. Does not crumble into my eyes.I've used so many brands, all prices, and this is the best that I am aware of.

Exactly what I was hoping for. Makes my lashes look longer and no clumping. I will buy this again.

I was really not expecting much from this mascara as I feel like I've tried them ALL; but I was surprised at how well it stays on without flaking(even after a 3 hour mountain bike ride!). It washes of easily with jojoba oil, or micellar water, and it feels light. No irritation on my sensitive skin/eyes. The ONLY complaint I have so far is that it takes multiple coats to get the thick eyelash look that I prefer.