Charlee Bear Dog Treat, 16-Ounce, Liver

My dogs love these treats and they are low calorie, so you cant spoil them too much!

Best dog treat! Had them shipped from USA but now on Amazon UK

I've been buying these treats for some years. They are a dry, crunchy treat, and similar in size and shape to an oyster cracker. I keep them in the cookie jar on my counter, near the back door, so they are handy for when the dogs come inside when called, training tricks, or just for looking cute. ;D For my dogs, these are not a high reward treat - they won't necessarily get the dog's attention in a very distracting or highly stimulating situation - but they are a good treat for other purposes of simple reinforcement. Here's my tip on pricing for a *16 oz bag* of Charlee Bears, which usually have a non-sale price of just over $5 in a store: - Under $5 is a good price. Under $4 is a really good price. - Under $3 is a _great_ price (i.e. Amazon add-on-item price for 2.99). Buy several bags. - If Over $6, you are paying more than you would at a pet store - shop elsewhere. Here's what I like about the treats: * Dogs like them. * Dry and crunchy, easy to keep in cookie jar (don't dry out from exposure like soft treats). * Only 3 calories per treat, so I can give several without worrying about making my dog fat. * Not a strong smell to humans, if you are sensitive to such things, but a good smell to dogs. * Few ingredients - simple and healthy. * Made with Poultry liver (not beef) - important if your dog is allergic or sensitive to beef. * Fit inside many treat dispenser toys, such as the Squirrel Dude and Kong Wobbler.

I use these as rewards for my guide dog when we are working. If you have not seen them, they are about the size of a Smartie, or an M&M if you aren't familiar with Smarties. They are also quite dry and hard which makes them ideal to carry in your pocket as they do not crumble or make a greasy mess. I only gave them four stars because I believe a more discerning dog than my present lab (who gobbles up EVERYTHING) would likely reject them. My previous German Shepherd would not have given them a second sniff. For the dog who is very treat-motivated, they are perfect.

We keep these on hand. Always good.

Our little dog loves them

I can't say enough good things about these treats. The ingredients are simple and wholesome, with no artificial additives - and yet the price is fantastic! You get a 16-ounce bag that is filled to the brim, and it lasts us forever even though we have two dogs who are ADDICTED to these things. My oldest dog McGinley has been eating these for years. His favorite flavor is liver, but he'll eat any of the varieties. He has dental issues, and these are so light and crispy. They remind me of oyster crackers. Yum! They're perfect for training too. My other dog Bitty is a new rescue, and we've been using these to teach her tricks. They're low in calories and I don't have to worry about giving her too many. Both of my dogs have sensitive bellies, and these don't affect them negatively whatsoever. I'll be buying these for life, and I always recommend them to friends.