HiWater 4396508 Refrigerator Filter Compatible with Whirlpool EDR5RXD1, W10186668, 4396510, NLC240V, 4396508P, Filter 5, 4392857, 46-9010 - 3 Pack

I struggle to find this specific type of filter at Walmart, target, Home Depot, etc. so I always order it here and it works just the same. It’s actually a little cheaper to buy here vs Walmart.

I got these because they were significantly cheaper than the name brand option or the options at the home improvement store. They look just like the name brand filter they replaced and fit fine into my refrigerator. That said, I have never had the water quality tested since I installed them. I have no idea how well they work. I can't taste anything funky, but my water tastes pretty alright without them, so it doesn't mean much.

This one wasn't as easy to install as previous filters, so much so that I broke the filter cap in my refrigerator trying to get this thing to turn and had to replace it. The second filter in the box fit better but it was still hard to turn it.I regret trying to save money buying this 3 pack and I ended up with only 2 usable filters and the expense of having to replace the filter cap.

Have used these this filters for several years and found them to work great. Excellent Price!

Let’s just be honest, I hate changing the fridge water filters as it’s been sometimes nearly impossible to turn them with our arthritic hands, not to mention laying down on ceramic tile floor to try. This brand has to be the easiest application I’ve ever used. My Kenmore Elite side by side, gulped it in like a pleasant dessert. I did not encounter any resistance like some of the others. I’m grateful that I found these. I like the flavor, the fit and now the fridge will help keep us hydrated 💦

Thank you so much, Great ! God bless ✝️❤️

These filters work well, but be sure that you match up your numbers/make/ model, etc. to make sure you get the correct ones. Once installed, flush for a couple of minutes.

They fit and I suppose they work.