4x Black Analog Thumb Stick Replacements, Compatible with Xbox One & Series S|X

Can’t really tell if the tips are plastic or rubber but it seems like a firm rubber, they fit fine and work great, especially for the money it gives you fresh sticks on two controllers for less than £2 per controller if you replace both sticks.

Using these on a Power-A controller. They were very easy to fit and seem really good quality. However mine are quite tight against the faceplate meaning the L1 stick press is VERY sensitive now. Not a deal breaker for me as I'm only using it for Rocket League but it might impact other games more severely. I would buy these again though as they are cheap and get the job done.

Really good quality, grippy tops. Have ordered others which have just been a plastic mould but these are great. Recommended!

The sticks aren't rubberized and are just hard plastic on the grips.

100% plastic, there is no rubber in them so it's horrible. Received a refund though without having to return but put them straight into the recycling box.

Really poor quality, thin and flimsy plastic. grips seem to be made of a poor quality plastic like rubber, if it even is rubber

Bought to replace a stick broken when the pad was thrown in anger during a game of COD. Fit in 10 minutes and pad like new. COD uninstalled and my pad is safe now, and my blood pressure lower.