Kaely 2Pcs Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Natural Black Eyeliner Cream for Waterline, L...

These gel eyeliner pencils glide on effortlessly and create a smooth, precise line without tugging. The color is rich, long-lasting, and stays in place throughout the day without smudging. I love how easy they are to apply, whether I’m creating a natural look or a bold eyeliner style. They are great quality, affordable, and have become a staple in my makeup routine. Highly recommended!

Didn’t work for me. Too greasy , doesn’t stay in , smears

First, I'm not an eyeshadow user. The only makeup I use at the age of 63 is eyeliner (mostly pencil, occasionally liquid) and dark red lipstick (preferably the long-last kind). I'm not sure why, because I've been retired for 4.5 years and only go out for doctor appointments, but... I don't like walking into my bathroom, looking into my mirror, and thinking "aaaaak!" I confess this makes me strange. But this is why I wear makeup at home. Most of my makeup routine is skincare. I need dark red lipstick to bring color to my face, and I need eyeliner to bring out my eyes. I don't wear mascara because it's a big fat waste of time & money for me. My lashes are short, sparse, thin, and worst of all, fine. Mascara doesn't even cling to my eyelashes. Who ever heard of that? And I'm a minimalist, but blush, bronzer, concealer, foundation... more aaaak! I'm too lazy to do all that. Anyway, Kaely eyeliner. I love the aesthetics of the containers. So cute! I love the eyeliner crayon. It takes no time at all to get a smoky eye. I just use a cotton swab and micellar water to wipe the residue clean. I love this product because, although it smears on my upper lid (I have hooded eyelids), the smears look intentional. This product is highly water-resistant. It does tend to smudge, but when I go out I carry a small pack of micellar water cotton swabs in my handbag. My skin is tan and my hair is (still) black, and the gray liner is amazing on me. The black is a bit more dramatic, so I use a lighter hand with it. (I've graduated from using just the gray to using the black and the gray together. Great results.) But really, this may be the easiest eye makeup for me out there, and it's inexpensive! Removal of makeup at night is easy: I rub Ponds cold cream over lips, eyes, and face, take a warm damp washcloth, rest it on my face, and then rub the cream off. My skin is soft and ready for serum, moisturizer, and eye cream. I think I only docked the one star because of the smudgeability of this product, but I really rate it a 4.5. If you're into the smoky, minimalist eye or easy products, you owe it to yourself to try this. I think you'll be surprisingly pleased. Thank you. **Update 3/4/25: Also an *excellent*, easy-to-use eyebrow pencil. **Update 3/27/25: To maintain control of the product when the point blunts: use an eyeliner brush to brush the tip and then apply accordingly. This will help maintain the tip and will also allow you to use the product when it reaches the base so you don't have to waste any of the crayon. I'm fickle when it comes to makeup, but I can't see myself deviating from this routine for the unforeseeable future. I'm in love with these cream eyeliners.

The Kaely Gray Gel Eyeliner Pencil offers a smooth and effortless application thanks to its creamy gel texture, allowing for both precise lines and softer blended looks. The pigmentation is well-balanced, giving a noticeable gray shade that enhances the eyes without being too harsh, making it suitable for everyday wear as well as more defined makeup styles. Once applied, it sets nicely and stays in place for hours with minimal smudging. The waterproof formula holds up well throughout the day without fading or transferring easily. It feels comfortable on the eyelids and glides on without tugging, which makes the application quick and easy. The pencil format is also very practical for on-the-go use. Overall, this is a reliable and versatile eyeliner that performs well and fits easily into a daily makeup routine.

Color was exactly the brown I wanted it to be. Goes on super smooth even thicker line. Which is why I ordered it. I use my other brown liners and do a thin original line let it dry, then put another this line on top of first line to get a thicker line. I do get my makeup from Ulta. Use a lot of Benefit for my liquid and crayon liners. Shipping and packaging was stellar.

Goes on easy but tip is fat so you definitely have clean up after. Kinda burns my eyes after putting on waterline. Been wearing for about an hour and have a transfer line from my top lid near my eyebrows. If you are looking for the grungy late 90s early 2000s look this is great but it is not for everyday and is not long wear

Keeps falling off the base! So it's difficult to get a straight eye line because it come off the base which is a BIG mess when your trying to get ready to go out. It fell in the sink, I had thick black mascara in and on the sink. Black on my hands and I can't get it back on the base without breaking it or smudging it all over the tube and the base! I bought a 2 pack and they are both the same wobbling around and hard to use..ughh!

The product promises 24hour wear, Day 1 I put it on my eyelid it looks amazing for 20 minutes the started to melt and migrate to different places on my face. Later in the day my eyes began to burn while I was at work, I when to the bathroom and washed off my makeup . Day2 I decided to put it in my water line my eyes immediately started to burn!!! Thought maybe it was somthing that was going to last for a few seconds but it got worse I almost couldn't open my eyes. I started removing the makeup in my waterline and to my surprise as I wipe it out of my waterline more of this eyeliner pools into the waterline!!! I feel it's also important to tell you that my allergies (sniffles and sneezing were actining up while using this product) After a solid 15 minutes of whipping and dabbing and blowing my nose. i take a look at the ingredients. pure ceresin ( natural wax that's common in cosmetics) Theobroma cacao ( coco butter) Synthetic wax (not specified but I'm hoping it's just the typical synthetic was that is aslo commonly used in cosmetics primarily made of synthetic materials such as petroleum-based hydrocarbons, ketones, and aldehydes. Ethyhexyl palpitate, a fatty acid ester that's used in cosmetics and skincare products. Isopropyl myristate, a synthetic oil and fatty acid ester with many uses in the cosmetic, food, and pharmaceutical industries Polyethylene, lightweight, durable, and inexpensive plastic that's used in many household products, including food containers, shopping bags, and bottles (this considered safe for cosmetic products) Kadlin, (COMPLEATLY UNKNOWN, GOOGLE CANT TELL YOU EITHER BECAUSE ITS NOT A CHEMICAL im left to assume this may be a typo for KAOLAN which is often used in sunscreen to treat skin. It important to know that kaolin is a silicate mineral it's used for many things like ceramic, paints and some cosmetics :Eye contact may cause mechanical irritation if exposed to excessive amounts of kaolin. Skin contact may aggravate existing dermatitis. Inhalation from prolonged and continuous exposure to excessive quantities of dust may aggravate existing asthmatic or respiratory conditions. Sorbitan oleate, a vegetable-based emulsifier and cleansing agent used in cosmetics and food. Microcrystalline wax, works primarily as a thickening agent that gives a solid, smooth feel to the cosmetic formulations Polyisobutene, a polymer that's used in cosmetics and other products. Pentaerythritol tetrakis AKA (bis-tert-butylhydroxyhydrocinnamate)synthetic antioxidant and heat stabilizer used in cosmetics, plastics, and other applications. ‼️phenomenon xyethanol‼️ can't find what is is but when you looks is up you will find a PDF file open to the public starting with this (In this study, the toxic effects of phenoxyethanol (Phy-Et), which is widely used in cosmetic industry) the pdf file was made to inform us of the students that was done in 2020 this compound has been tested and results show, after exposure , Phy-Et resulted in some anatomical damages and changes such as necrosis, cell deformation and thickening of the cortex cell wall in root tip meristem cells‼️ Ethyhexylglycerol, a synthetic chemical used in cosmetics and other products as a preservative, emollient, and skin-softener. Caprylyl glyool, an alcohol-based ingredient used in many cosmetics and personal care products. ‼️Fragrance ‼️scents or perfumes present in eye cosmetics like eyeshadow, mascara, or eyeliner, which can be a potential irritant for the sensitive eye area, often causing redness, itchiness, or tearing. CI 45410, CI 15850, CI 77491, CI 77492 and CI 77499 are all approved cosmetic dyes.